Quote:
Originally Posted by ekim008
Odd you could not find fault with any republican cabinet member.you must be one
|
Well, pre-Kennedy, most administrations had reasonably good cabinets, especially Truman. Kennedy brought in the eggheads but had Rusk as Sec of State. Rusk was/is considered the weakest Sec. of State in the last century by historians. McNamara thought he could run defense like an accountant which explains most of his decisions. He appointed his unqualified brother has AG. Johnson, on the other hand, had a very good cabinet. As did Nixon, excepting that I personally did not like or trust Kissinger. I didn't count Ford due to his short tenure and he essentially kept Nixon's cabinet except the aforementioned Mitchell. Carter's cabinet were pretty much like Carter, forgettable. Cyrus Vance as Sec of State for two years was amusing though. Griffin Bell as AG was a disaster.
Reagan's first cabinet is possibly the best overall after he replaced Haig with Schultz. Weinberger was exceptional at Defense. Smith, Block and Schweiker were outstanding (Schweiker was a Democrat and Reagan picked him for HHS. He was very good). Any cabinet that contained George Schultz and James Baker is better than average.
Clinton's cabinet member for the most part, while liberal, were at least competent managers. (at least the major members) Espy would have gone to prison for corruption but died in a plane crash. Christopher and Albright at State were exceptionally weak but Clinton fashioned himself after Kennedy and decided he would be the state department in the white house. Reich was by far the smartest and extremely liberal Labor Sec. I have great respect for him but do not really agree with his politics. Reno, she was his fourth choice, was weak and not really qualified but managed to be competent.
GWB's first cabinet was decent to good. I did not think Ashcroft was strong or qualified. Rice, Powell, Rumsfeld, Snow, and Thompson were exceptional.
And NO, I am not a Republican. I am an economist and historian and libertarian though.
CORRECTION: Ron Brown was under investigation and was killed in a crash. Espy was actually tried for accepting bribes. He plead not guilty and was acquitted. In the most ironic turn, two companies actually plead guilty to paying him illegal bribes. One of those companies, Sun-Diamond later got a reversal. The other company was Tyson Foods, a large Clinton supporter.