I go to the Elite Cigar Cafe and like it. They're helpful, have a good sized humidor and a full bar. They also boast of having the best french dip sandwich in town but mine is better.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/70eeb/70eeba045d4b363ad1cf267424d01b887c48d4a1" alt="Wink"
There's a patio to relax on and the cafe is right at Midway and Beltline.
I usually go for a medium body stick. Oliva V, Romeo y Julieta (Dominican, not the Romeo #2 ), Rocky Patel, Arturo Fuente, the occasional Gurkha or a mild house roll. In the fall, I take my humidor to the office and share a little piece of Havana that's been rolled on the thighs of virgins
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/48c52/48c525b30b1808793dd946e61d3954f4d99144fa" alt="Smile"
As for the forbidden fruit, it tastes like contraband but that doesn't make it better.
Edit to add: I always stock a few Opus X, twice a year!