Blackbeards is a better deal, if that's all you are looking for. The all-inclusives like Playboy and
MyWildVacations cater to guys looking for more luxury.
Blackbeards is far out of town and away from the beach -- you need a taxi to go pretty much anywhere. The girls there are average -- some gorgeous, some not. You pay for everything, so if you are not much of a drinker it's not too expensive. However I know many guys who drink a lot and like to buy drinks for the girls and create a party atmosphere. They can spend WAY more on drinks and food than the rest of their stay combined.
At an all-inclusive, you don't worry about individual costs. Yes, it will be more than Blackbeards. But it is also hassle free. Someone picks you up at the airport and drives you to the villa. Each day you pick out your girl(s). You have a luxury room in a beachside resort. There's someone there to drive you down the road to the tourist areas. Most nights there's a party or show -- lingerie night, costume parties, pool parties, etc. Or else they'll gather up those who want to go and descend on a disco club with all of the guys and girls together. And of course all the food and drink is included.
Guys who go to the all-inclusives just want to walk off the plane and be catered to. No need to worry about speaking Spanish or getting lost on the way to the resort. Every day, there's something to do and a gorgeous girl to do it with. It's not for everyone, but it's really not that expensive. I see cruises and tour packages well over $1000 per day all the time. And they don't include the sex.