Welcome to ECCIE - Sign up today!

John_TX · 08-25-2010, 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rand Al'Thor

This is a bit hypocritical, isn't it?

in what way? i haven't posted a review yet. and in this discussion thread both sides are able to tell their side of the story.

John_TX · 08-25-2010, 09:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sexy Roxanne

So do you think just because it is in the ladies area that they can't smell bullshit even if its a provider claiming it? I know for a fact plenty of ladies have been called on their bullshit in the ladies area. Just like I am sure for the same in the mens area...
If nothing happened don't stress, people will see through bullshit. I have said all I have to say, I am not being in this drama of this thread anymore. Good luck to the both of you. BTW..when you post the link from coed, the ladies can still see you're side and her's. so it is not just one sided.

i think if that is the case then there is no use in posting it to begin with, especially when they can see it right here.

i think it is simply wrong to post info in which the other party has no ability to rebut clearly false accusations. post a link to this discussion and i think it is much more fair.

Rand Al'Thor · 08-25-2010, 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_TX

in what way? i haven't posted a review yet. and in this discussion thread both sides are able to tell their side of the story.

Didn't you post earlier in this thread with a link to where you might have shared your side of the story in what might be men only channel?

BTW, if no session took place (I know you're going to love this), there is no review.

John_TX · 08-25-2010, 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rand Al'Thor

Didn't you post earlier in this thread with a link to where you might have shared your side of the story in what might be men only channel?

BTW, if no session took place (I know you're going to love this), there is no review.

what i posted in the men's section was not the full side of my story, nor any false allegations. i posted a comment about her services Staff Edit..ML info posted in open..Spacemtn..AustinModStaff i think that is clearly different than this full-blown post we have here.

so, no, not hypocritical. not like i started a post in the Men's Lounge, Staff edit..ML info posted in open...Spacemtn..AustinModStaf f

nuglet · 08-25-2010, 09:39 AM

Aaallllrighty then.... Who's got the popcorn?

Rand Al'Thor · 08-25-2010, 09:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_TX

what i posted in the men's section was not the full side of my story, nor any false allegations. i posted a comment about her services that Staff Edit..Spacemtn..ML info posted in open. i think that is clearly different than this full-blown post we have here.

so, no, not hypocritical. not like i started a post in the Men's Lounge, i only added my comments to an existing thread about her, Staff Edit..Spacemtn..ML info posted in open..

I see. So the amount of details, and the fact that you didn't start your own thread changes the fact that you shared your side of the story in an exclusive forum that are men only, and that you complained about a woman's side of the story (regardless of length and amount of detail) being shared where you have no recourse or argument. As for her accusations being false, that, at this point, is up to the readers to decide for themselves.

I would also advise you to refrain from disclosing the nature and details of Men's Lounge posts, unless the person who posted makes it public.

Elephant · 08-25-2010, 09:43 AM

How not to start your career...lol

Quote:

Originally Posted by nuglet

Aaallllrighty then.... Who's got the popcorn?

Spacemtn · 08-25-2010, 09:43 AM

Let's all remember:

No posting of private communications, ie, PM's, e mails, texts, etc.

Everyone has the right to post what they want where they want as long as it is respectful and doesn't fall into areas that are forbidden.

Reviews are only for sessions that actually took place.

Private area communications that have been posted by others are not to be posted or discussed in open forums.

Spacemtn
AustinModStaff

John_TX · 08-25-2010, 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rand Al'Thor

I see. So the amount of details, and the fact that you didn't start your own thread changes the fact that you shared your side of the story in an exclusive forum that are men only, and that you complained about a woman's side of the story (regardless of length and amount of detail) being shared where you have no recourse or argument. As for her accusations being false, that, at this point, is up to the readers to decide for themselves.

I would also advise you to refrain from disclosing the nature and details of Men's Lounge posts, unless the person who posted makes it public.

evidently i smell a white knight here. yes, the fact that i didnt start a tirade on the boards does mean something. are you saying that i am not allowed to chime in on a thread? i am saying that the other roxanne (not the OP but the one who is offering to post info she knows nothing about to defame me in a ladies' only area) shouldnt be offering to regurgitate info that she knows nothing about on behalf of someone she knows nothing about (by her own admission).

yes, alot of us guys vent in the men's area. if you read that thread in the Men's Lounge i am not the first or second guy to vent about her. it's not hyprocritical. i am not the first or second person to have said something.

so Mr. White Knight, when are you getting your free session with Roxanne on Demand?

Rand Al'Thor · 08-25-2010, 10:01 AM

You may want to go back and read this thread over. As I have no first hand knowledge of Roxanne, the OP, I have made no comments defending or attacking her. I'm not sure what your definition of a white knight is, but my definition does not fit my behavior in this thread. To answer your question, I have no sessions scheduled with Roxanne, free or otherwise. Yes, this looks great for your credibility and the claim that she is the one making false accusations.

I said nothing about you not being allowed to chime in on a thread. I know many of us vent in the men's area. The fact that you are or are not the minority opinion has nothing to do with the hypocrisy of calling BS for her side of the story being posted in an area where you have no rebuttal, when you've already shared your side in an area where she has no rebuttal.

John_TX · 08-25-2010, 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rand Al'Thor

You may want to go back and read this thread over. As I have no first hand knowledge of Roxanne, the OP, I have made no comments defending or attacking her. I'm not sure what your definition of a white knight is, but my definition does not fit my behavior in this thread. To answer your question, I have no sessions scheduled with Roxanne, free or otherwise. Yes, this looks great for your credibility and the claim that she is the one making false accusations.

I said nothing about you not being allowed to chime in on a thread. I know many of us vent in the men's area. The fact that you are or are not the minority opinion has nothing to do with the hypocrisy of calling BS for her side of the story being posted in an area where you have no rebuttal, when you've already shared your side in an area where she has no rebuttal.

i have first hand knowledge. she does not. she is offering to move information that she knows not a damn thing about to an area where providers can read it and make a decision about my credibility as member.

anything more i need to spell out for you? have a good time at your free session.

poseidon · 08-25-2010, 10:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_TX

have a good time at your free session.

I know I'll wish I had stayed out of this nonsense.... but wasn't John just complaining that Roxanne's accusation against him was based on information that she couldn't verify (who it was that the hotel manager got their info from)? Yet, John, here you are fabricating a wild accusation against both the provider as well as another board member. Your credibility wanes.

78704 · 08-25-2010, 10:26 AM

I put John_TX on my ignore list weeks ago.

Rand Al'Thor · 08-25-2010, 10:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_TX

i have first hand knowledge. she does not. she is offering to move information that she knows not a damn thing about to an area where providers can read it and make a decision about my credibility as member.

anything more i need to spell out for you? have a good time at your free session.

What you called 'bull shit' on was of her story being shared in an arena where you had no recourse, and my call out on your hypocrisy was based on the fact that you had a problem with it after you've shared your side of the story where she had no recourse. Now, if you want to change that and say you have no objection to her story being shared, but Sexy Roxanne conveying information that she has no first hand knowledge of, then knock yourself out.

Again, your attempts to accuse me of being a white knight or getting a free session without any evidence seems contradictory to how you want to portray yourself in this thread. If you would like to keep at it, please present some logical reasons how you have come to this conclusion. Otherwise, I would advise that you stop attacking my character and ethics.

ThatHarleyGuy · 08-25-2010, 10:34 AM

First of all, the only thing you both agree on on is that the session never actually happened. Therefore, no review, good or bad.
Second, neither of you have earned credability with the existing members yet, so both of your rantings are being ignored.
So, drop it. Sounds like it was best it never happened. Subseuent arguments by either of you on this subject will only detract from your respective board cred. Walk away. Work on your reps in new discussions on other subjects, about other people. Put each other on your respective ignore lists, and be at peace.

Update: Now you're going after her in the Welcome Wagon? Give it a rest.
http://www.eccie.net/showpost.php?p=533135&postcount=9