Another example of why the ECCIE review system is broke beyond economical repair.
Maybe Carly did deserve a "no" - who knows (he said / she said)? But she at least deserved to receive it from someone who was ARTICULATE and CREDIBLE. Ash nor Clubbie are either. Clubby joins the board and decides ... "Hey I think I'll "break in" this here review system with a "NO" right off the bat!" His FIRST review was a "NO" review. Not a smart move, playing with the review system is like playing with fire. If you're gonna write a "NO" review - better think five times first and make sure you have your backup.
Or better yet ... why not just TELL the girl that you intend to give her a "NO" recommendation? That's the alpha-male balls thing to do. Ambushing the gal in a review that she's not allowed to read is a fucking pussy move and I don't give a SHIT who pulls it.
This is the girl's livelihood. If you're gonna give her a "NO" at least do the BIG BOY thing and make sure she's the first to know. Tell her "offline" face to face before you write the review. Tell her WHY you're going to give her a "no" (leaving it in RoS that she can't see - WTF purpose does that serve and how can she correct any shortfalls?). How would you like it if YOUR Boss did your yearly evaluation in secret - and you just "found out" when the secretary says ... "Hey you got utterly DICKED on your eval - and no I can't tell you why." ????
How do you make that right as employee? How do you correct your shortfalls? What course of appeal do you have?
If you don't have the balls to tell her she's getting a "no" review and why she's getting it - you shouldn't write the review. I know a lot of chicken-shit guys don't agree with this but ... hey I just call it like I see them.
And saying that "she's a black girl - nothing special" ...
Well the Black girls got offended by that but everyone should be offended because it reveals a "chattel" attitude toward all escorts.