Ugh, I hate these he said/she said threads, and I predict this going South very quickly and turning into an all-out yelling match. Let's be honest, nothing is every decided or resolved by these threads, as we all know about the three sides to any situation. We'll here the first two, his and hers, but the third one (truth) never seems to find it's way out.
I predict Reya accusing him of some horrible act/making her uncomfortable/requesting or indulging in illegal activities, and Italiaman saying, "That's bullshit!" or something along those lines. Some will side with him, some with her, nobody outside of the two will definitively know the truth. Regardless of the outcome, it should be entertaining. Proceed!