I've always provided in the loop. Never exactly downtown, but close by. Have always been in the Heights & the Trose. I am back in the Trose now and people seem to love it.
I always vote for inner loop. I think if your place has designated parking, people will be ok with it.
If y'all hadn't noticed, dt tends to actually have less traffic nowadays than many other inner loop areas. I drive through regularly and often use it as an alternative route to get places bc the traffic tends to be a lot less crazy.
Also, glad to see you back lady!!!!!