Dressed up. She doesn't have to be in a dress but definately wouldn't hurt.
It is coming off anyways
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/48c52/48c525b30b1808793dd946e61d3954f4d99144fa" alt="Smile"
.
As far as makeup and looking their best, absolutely. You can always tell which ones go out of their way. Do I keep repeating with dates with her? heck yeah.
The ones that look like they got out of bed isn't a good impression.
I wouldn't show up like I got out of bed and not showered either so I would like the same courtesy.
I do take notice, hair done, lipstick and all. For gals they get pedis, yes it is super sexy cute painted toenails with the peep toe heels on. Heels are 50/50 if they stay on or off while playing
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/70eeb/70eeba045d4b363ad1cf267424d01b887c48d4a1" alt="Wink"
. I do really appreciate that and go out of my way to see them again if we click.
The gal doesn't have to wear Gucci, Coach, Prada, or Lous to impress me. A cute Old Navy dress would impress me just as much with some cute flats. From there on, it is how she treats me.