Now this is a conversation that I will gladly join!
Cigars are classed and treated much like wines, and while I prefer dark, dry, full-bodied wines (Argentinian, Italian, Peruvian), my taste in cigars trends towards a lighter-bodied smoke. For my experience with medium to heavy body cigars, my humble opinion is that the Gurhka Evil resides at the top of that class, to be interchanged with Padron Family Reserve.
Personally, I prefer light-bodied cigars; cuban seed grown into Dominican or Nicaraguan leaf. I got into cigars via Cohiba, but those are the GPS of the cigar world.
My all-time favorite cigar is the
Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne Edition.
It's flavorful, and combines well with a dry dark red, blended whiskey, or your favorite single malt. All the flavor of an $18 Cohiba, for a $4-5 Toro.
A close second, but a nonetheless second - which means I don't smoke them because of how much I enjoy the Perdomo comes
Oliva Connecticut Reserve.
Both the Perdomo and the Oliva can be found in pretty much any cigar shop (and the Gurhka), and many cigar shops report that the Perdomo 10th Anniversary is actually their best selling cigar.
Finally, worth trying at least once in your life is a Davidoff. Maduro for those who like the heavy flavor, Grand Cru for those who like the light flavor. In provider terms, if Cohiba has GPS, Davidoff is the UTR SB.
Life is short, enjoy it.