Quote:
Originally Posted by Dreamgurrl
Most Sex Workers want decriminalization not legalization. And not under the Nordic model which punishes the buyer. There is a lot to unpack surrounding decrim and the current laws we are navigating.
As with most industries, legalization creates an even more dangerous black market for both suppliers and buyers.
Legalization and regulation are not the answer. We have a right to bodily autonomy and no government has any right to regulate a persons autonomy.
|
I get what you are saying but I don't think it's possible to have decriminalization without legalization. The two are not mutually the same given the exchange of one thing of value for another. If it was without compensation, then yes I could see it. But as is, it's a business based off service and rate.
Of course there is a black market for everything....but,
Example of my point, from a consumer stand point, how many people go to Walmart and buy their needs. Compare that to how many people use black market channels for their needs. I would venture a guess that most go to Walmart because of ease, convenience, availability, legality (such as pharmaceutical supplies), and the expectations that they will most likely get something that meets their minimal needs.
Now please, I know this is not a apples to apples comparison but I am trying to convey a point. That if something is out there, in the open, and works under the current set of legislation and laws, it will be more appealing and accepting to a larger group. This industry has always been pushed under the carpet and has been given a negative rap because of it. Sometimes there is real legitimacy for that negative image too. A large portion of general acceptance is openness. Legalization would absolutely do that over time. And regulations would also absolutely help ease that over in the long run.
Absolutely, every individual has a right to bodily autonomy and no government has any right to regulate a persons autonomy. But also keep in mind that every profession/job is one in which a individual sells their body and skill set. Like it not, every person who collects a paycheck that is on the books is required by law to pay taxes. That means that about 1/3 of a working life pays for the government. Someone buys something, there's sales tax. Someone invests money, they are taxed on interest or the sale of said investment. It's something to think about. People's autonomy to earn a living in one form or another, is expected to pay for government. It's not right but everyone does it everyday.
Even thoughI absolutely don't agree with this completely, and too many take advantage of it, it does afford some forms of assistance if needed.
Regardless, the point I'm trying to make is that the current system and laws aren't going to fundamentally change. To some extent we are stuck with what there is and have to try and work with what little we have.
I still feel that the overall state of the industry is mostly honest in the sense it delivers on services. However moving forward legalization is a better choice because it could be a way to reduce theft, trafficking, substance abuse, etc.
Making sex work legal?
My Bio Page - Pennsylvania - Pittsburgh
My Bio Page - Ohio
Then what happened? Republicans are now trying to RESCIND all the mail-in and absentee and early voting provisions of the COVID-era 2020 election. There might be "experiments" in either "de-criminalization" and "legal prostitution" in different cities and areas. Both Republicans and Democrats will conclude what they think the "effects" are in due time....
