Just because the peanut gallery responds is not a reason to close a thread.
DD made no request to the peanuts to get back on topic. Highwayman commented about guys with too much time on their hands and gave a cheezy smile to his own "please, check your pm's".
If you look through some of the latest reviews, you will again see DD has been sending his check your pm's to guys:
Review: Monday Night w/Hunter
Review: Seductive & Enthusiastic Jamie
Just for these two examples, the reviews answered anything I would have looked for. If the thread was still open, that is where I would have posted.
Iso, you as the originator of the thread could have
asked to have it closed when it went off track or after you received your answer from DD. You didn't do this, and I will contend DD should not have closed the thread.