Should review comments be completely disabled?

[corona]

naah, leave 'em be. If some people are annoying, perhaps more judicious use of the block button should be applied.

[TexTushHog]

I think comments in response to reviews often add value. And I see not benefit in eliminating them. Drama will just move elsewhere.

[Randall Creed]

I'm sick of living in a world where people can't handle the bad with the good. They want life set on the PUSSY level (meaning easy), where there's no confrontation, no disagreement, no tough skin, no nothing, but just boring silence.

Hell naaw! Leave reviews the way they are.

[pyramider]

Originally Posted by Admiral Giggle

And have pyramider stroke out when he can't ad more useless taint comments?

You need to do a little research first as to why taint is commented.

[Recurve Jones]

Originally Posted by Randall Creed

I'm sick of living in a world where people can't handle the bad with the good. They want life set on the PUSSY level (meaning easy), where there's no confrontation, no disagreement, no tough skin, no nothing, but just boring silence.

Hell naaw! Leave reviews the way they are.

There's more than enough drama in other parts of this site, you've been here long enough to know that. Everyone has the right to an opinion, but I personally feel I could do without the brown nosing, comments to bump the review, trolls trying to start drama or guys "who may have seen her also" have an opinion of the review that is not the reviewer's opinion.

On the last reason, it does not matter what others think, the OP's review is HIS review and HIS opinion of the session HE paid for, which is all that matters.

[Randall Creed]

Originally Posted by Recurve Jones

There's more than enough drama in other parts of this site, you've been here long enough to know that. Everyone has the right to an opinion, but I personally feel I could do without the brown nosing, comments to bump the review, trolls trying to start drama or guys "who may have seen her also" have an opinion of the review that is not the reviewer's opinion.

On the last reason, it does not matter what others think, the OP's review is HIS review and HIS opinion of the session HE paid for, which is all that matters.

That's what gives the board its well roundedness, its kick-assery and shit. I've been on a board where they dumped comments on reviews. That board died a brutal, painful death, years ago.

When you take away interactive banter on a board, it's going to turn into shit. It is perfect? No, but it's better this way than what you're suggesting. Besides, if they do remove comments from reviews, it'll just migrate over to coed and ML.

Why? Because people like to talk about shit.

[Recurve Jones]

Originally Posted by Randall Creed

That's what gives the board its well roundedness, its kick-assery and shit. I've been on a board where they dumped comments on reviews. That board died a brutal, painful death, years ago.

When you take away interactive banter on a board, it's going to turn into shit. It is perfect? No, but it's better this way than what you're suggesting. Besides, if they do remove comments from reviews, it'll just migrate over to coed and ML.

Why? Because people like to talk about shit.

This is my entire point, they should migrate to coed and/or ML. These are bullshit repositories. But if you think disabling comments would be the death of "this" site, I have no experiwnce with that, so more power to you. I find it ironic none of the ladies are commenting here!